It should be noted that while Brummie may sound similar to other accents in the West Midlands, it is not the same. But population mobility in recent years has blurred the distinction between accents, as is has in most regions of the country.
Why is Brummie so unpopular?
It can’t be a coincidence that so many native English speakers dislike the Brummie accent. It is thought that people scorn it because Brummie can sound a little lazy. In addition, unlike many English accents, Brummie features a downward intonation at the end of each sentence. This causes the accent to lack vibrancy. Brummie is a somewhat monotone accent and so doesn’t sing like Scouse, the Liverpool accent, and many others. Interestingly, non-native speakers don’t seem to dislike Brummie or to find it difficult to understand.
As people perceive Brummie to be lazy and dull, the accent has become associated with both a lack of imagination and low intelligence. This is extremely unfortunate for the people of Birmingham. It isn’t helpful to have a Brummie accent when you are applying for a job outside of the region.
Birmingham has rarely been chosen as a location for TV series and movies. Production companies have feared that the local accent might be off-putting for viewers and have not wanted to risk poor ratings for their programmes. Things have changed in recent years as the hit show Peaky Blinders is set in Birmingham. However, the making of this hugely popular series highlighted another issue with Brummie.
Brummie is a very difficult accent to master, even for native English speakers. Actors trying to mimic the accent tend to use too many facial movements and can end up sounding as if they are from Liverpool. Brummies don’t employ many facial movements when speaking but do pout their lips. A less than subtle approach to this tendency can leave actors doing goldfish impressions!
What does Brummie sound like?
Birmingham is located in the middle of England and so features aspects of both northern and southern accents. This is another reason why those mimicking Brummie often get it so wrong. Here are the most obvious features of Brummie:
- /i/ as in five and like is pronounced as /oy/. This is a feature of many Irish dialects and may be the result of a large number of Irish immigrants having settled in Birmingham.
- /u/ as in hut is lengthened to sound like /oo/ so that hut become hoot.
- /o/ as in go can sound lazy as with the cockney accent.
- /a/ as in day can also sound lazy and similar to cockney.
- /ar/ as in star sounds lazy and shortened so that it becomes /a/ as in cap.
- /i/ as in pit becomes /ea/ as in heat.
- The letter /g/ is effectively pronounced twice when followed by a vowel or in words ending in ing.
- The letter/h/ at the beginning of words is not articulated so that hat becomes at.
- The letter /t/ at the end of words may not be articulated so that becomes tha.
- /oa/ Can sound like/ou/. The word goat then sounds like gout.
- Most Brummies use northern /a/ in words such as bath.
- Some Brummies will pronounce /s/ at the end of a word as /z/.
Here’s a video of Ozzy Osbourne who has never lost his distinctive Brummie drawl: